A Single Man (2009)
Directed By:
Tom Ford
Starring:
Colin Firth: George
Julianne Moore: Charlie
Matthew Goode: Jim
Nicholas Hoult: Kenny
Rating:

I Like Your Style, Dude
A Single Man, fashion designer Tom Ford's first film, is all about appearances. Taking place mostly in an immaculately appointed house in Los Angeles, nothing seems out of place for it's owner, George (Colin Firth), an English ex-pat who teaches English at a small university in California. Nothing seems out of place because he spends most of his time arranging the details of his life to fit the acceptable American narrative; in truth, everything is going to hell.George has heart problems, dreams of drowning and, worst of all, just lost his lover in a car accident. He finds out over the phone that the family hadn't even planned on informing him, let alone invite him to the funeral, which is a family only affair. George is a gay man, and, having lost his partner, must now move forward in a world where his relationship isn't considered real love. To the world, it may as well have never happened.
George spends the next eight months haunting his home, his office, his classroom. What else can he do? One morning, he puts out an extra suit, writes a few letters, slides open the drawer of his desk, and takes out a revolver. On his way home from work, he buys bullets for the gun. It's obvious what he plans to do, he's even set plans with other people later in the evening so they'll come looking for him when he goes missing.
There's a lot going on that suggests that life for George maybe isn't as miserable as it seems. There's a student in one of his classes, for example, who seems particularly interested in the details of his social life, and not much interested in his girlfriend. There's also the matter of his dinner plans with Charley (Julianne Moore), who is the only person he's talked to about his relationship. She and George used to go out, but nothing came of it. Now that they're both older and still single, she proposes that they try it again.
The dinner scene, probably the most hyped piece of A Single Man outside of Colin Firth's performance as a whole, is just crushing. It's one of the few times that George unleashes his emotions and asserts that what he had with Jim was real. Firth is a real powerhouse there, but, sitting in the theater, I kind of fell in line with the group of people who said that Moore went over-the-top. Not that it brought down the meat of the scene, just that she was too much. Thinking over it a bit, I got why Charley was portrayed the way she was: Single and getting older, Charley is just as depressed about her state of affairs as George is his, and is doing her best to appear fine when, really, she's on the verge of a nervous breakdown. In retrospect, I think Moore was great, but I can understand why one would think otherwise.
There are several other scenes that are similarly great, chief among them coming early in the film, when George is told over the telephone that Jim has died and that he isn't invited to the funeral. The subplot with the student (Nicholas Hoult) just feels undeveloped, which may be no fault of Ford's, but I never really got a feel for Kenny, who does so much to get George's attention, but never gets around to having the truly meaningful conversation with George that is built-up from the beginning. It could be due to the fact that it's the first day where he's had a real interaction with George, after drinks, swimming near-naked in the ocean, and finding a naked picture of a man in George's medicine drawer, I'd expect a little more backbone than that. Ford does a tremendous job of building the anticipation towards this conversation that never happens, but since it never happens, that energy has nowhere to go.
The movie's main flaw may be that it's too subtle. Ford gives us one hell of a timebomb when he sends the likable George off to do his chores on the last day of his life, but you never hear the clock ticking. Sure, there are signs, clues, inklings as to how George is feeling and what George is thinking, but they're so far under the surface that, most times, they're barely a blip on the radar. I'm sure that this is intentional--Firth,who is splendid, wouldn't have been half as good if the script called for him to lash out or weep at every turn--but there's little to no sense of true suspense. The whole thing is on the backburner; either he does it, or he doesn't. I'm willing to believe that's also an issue that could largely be attributed to the source material, and would almost certainly bet that a second viewing would clear things up immensely. Problem is that there are plenty of people, like me, who haven't read the Isherwood novel to know what's really beneath George's surface, and the honest truth is that A Single Man will be lucky if a wide audience gives it a first viewing. While this is certainly a very good movie, it's also a slow-burning period piece that uses a gay relationship as the backdrop for a story about love and loss. That's one hell of a hook, and it got me, but it won't be for everyone.
































